Last updated: November 11, 2026
Did you know that around one in four employees click a faulty link in phishing simulation tests?
A phishing simulation is basically a cybersecurity training exercise, usually conducted by organizations. In these phishing simulations, an organization sends fake but realistic phishing messages via text messages, emails, even phone calls to its employees to help test and improve their ability to spot and handle real-world cyber threats. Phishing simulations for employees are meant to give them first-hand experience in recognizing, avoiding, and reporting any sort of cyberattack before a breach becomes severe.
In this blog, Mitigata breaks down more on what it takes to run an effective phishing simulation for employees along with tips on what to measure, and what to do with the results.
Mitigata is an IRDAI-licensed, AI-native cyber resilience company serving more than 800 businesses across cybersecurity, compliance, cyber insurance and incident response. This guide shows a team with no dedicated security staff how to run a first phishing test and read the result.
Why Does A Phishing Simulation Teach More Than An Annual Training Deck?
Training decks on cyber threats and security awareness often fall short because passive learning doesn’t always prep someone for real-world cyber-attacks. Employees may often simply slide through corporate presentations without any focused attention. They may also answer multiple choice questions correctly in instances where organizations run objective tests. But without a practical phishing simulation test, they may still fall prey to modern day phishing attempts because of the sheer sophistication of these attacks.
A practical phishing simulation for employees transforms theoretical notes into actual awareness. Safely exposing employees to realistic attacks as part of their everyday work allows them to develop muscle memory for spotting the right kind of red flags like suspicious sender addresses, malicious attachments, fake links. Phishing simulations for employees are more effective because an employee may not be able to recall a slide they may have read six months ago but they will remember what they have experienced through an actual phishing simulation test.
How Mitigata Helps Build a Phishing-Resilient Workforce
Employees are often the first line of defence against phishing attacks. Mitigata combines realistic phishing simulations, cybersecurity expertise, and security awareness training to help businesses identify employee vulnerabilities and strengthen their human defence against cyber threats.
Here’s how Mitigata adds value:
- Realistic Attack Simulations: Test employee awareness through phishing scenarios across email, SMS, and workplace communication channels.
- Targeted Security Awareness: Help employees recognise phishing attempts, suspicious links, and social engineering tactics.
- Actionable Risk Insights: Identify risky behaviours, measure employee responses, and prioritise training needs.
- End-to-End Cybersecurity Support: Connect phishing awareness initiatives with broader security and risk management strategies.
Phishing Doesn't Stop at Email. Neither Should Your Training.
Prepare employees for evolving threats with Mitigata’s phishing simulations across email, SMS, and workplace communication channels.
What Should Organizations Simulate In A Phishing Awareness Training Test For Employees?
Modern cyber attackers use a variety of methods today to breach organizational defences. A robust phishing simulation program for employees should ideally cover several possible real-life attack scenarios, especially the ones given below:
- Phishing link as a test: In this phishing simulation for employees, the organization sends an email containing a link that leads to a malicious landing page. This test is meant to check whether employees are paying attention to URLs before clicking on them.
- Malicious attachment as a test: In this phishing simulation test, the organization sends emails with realistic (but malicious) attachments in common formats like a .pdf, or .docx, or .zip. These are designed to replicate HR forms, invoices, parcel delivery or shipping updates. All of this is done to check if employees open untrusted files without first reviewing who has sent it and if the attachment is authentic.
- Fake login form test: This phishing simulation for employees directs them to a fake login page that mimics commonly used tools like Google Word Docs or Microsoft 365 to test whether employees recognize fraudulent login portals before entering their sensitive information or credentials.
- Phishing QR code test or ‘Quishing’ test: In this phishing simulation, the organization utilizes QR codes embedded within emails directing employees to scan it with their mobile devices. This test is conducted to check their security awareness across mobile endpoints.
- WhatsApp phishing test: This phishing simulation is conducted by sending socially engineered messages through commonly used instant messaging platforms like WhatsApp to test the employee’s level of vigilance outside of standard email or other business communication channels.
How To Run Your First Phishing Simulation Awareness Test Campaign In Five Simple Steps
Phishing simulations for employees are the need of the hour. Running them doesn’t have to be a complicated process. Mitigata’s five simple steps can help you get started in a matter of moments:
- Define Your Phishing Test Objectives and Whitelist Test Infrastructure: Establish clear goals for the phishing campaign and coordinate with your IT or other security and engineering teams to whitelist simulation IP addresses and domains so that emails aren’t blocked by internal firewalls or spam filters.
- Select Realistic Cyber Attack Scenarios: You must choose scenarios that are most relevant to the industry and to the jobs the employees being tested work at. For instance, for someone in HR, HR related queries can be used, for someone in finance, customer payment notifications can be used, for someone in IT, a password reset simulation might work better.
- Launch The Phishing Simulation Campaign: Schedule the phishing simulation to run over a set duration, two weeks is usually a good timeframe. This is better than sending all the phishing emails at once. It makes the phishing simulation much more realistic.
- Deliver Instant Training For ‘Failures’: Keep a real-time check on the performance of these tests. In short, keep aside a list of those employees who have interacted with the phishing simulation campaign by clicking on a link. Ensure that these employees are immediately redirected to a training page explaining what happened and what indicators they missed.
- Analyse Data And Report Results: Gather key metrics from the phishing simulations to understand your baseline risk and present these insights to your leadership and security teams to determine what next steps need to be taken at an organizational level.
Understanding What A Good Click Rate Looks Like In A Phishing Simulation Test For Employees
Organizations frequently observe click rates between 20% and 30% which means around one in four employees end up becoming ‘victims’ during these phishing simulations.
A ‘good’ click rate depends on the campaign maturity:
- Initial Benchmark: 15% – 25% click rate is typical for organizations running their first phishing simulation test.
- Mature Security Culture: What organizations should do is aim for a failure rate below 5%. High security organizations who have conducted many phishing simulations for employees over the years usually achieve click rates under 3%.
Can Your Employees Spot a Phishing Attack in Time?
Find out with Mitigata’s realistic phishing simulations, employee response tracking, and expert-backed security awareness guidance.
Next Steps: What To Do With The Employees Who Click On Wrong Links During The Phishing Simulation Test?
How you respond to phishing simulation failures will dictate the success of your security awareness program. Attackers are smarter than before and even the most cautious employee may fall victim to cyber threats. Here’s what you can do when your employees have become ‘victims’ during a phishing simulation program.
- Avoid Punitive Measures Or Penalties: Do not publicly shame or reprimand employees who click simulated links. If you do, it will cause employees to hide actual security incidents out of fear.
- Provide Instant Feedback: Direct the employee to a dedicated page immediately after the faulty click where further information is given to help them understand what the red flags they missed were.
- Assign Targeted Learning Sessions: Enrol repeat faulty clickers into short refresher training modules where they can be given demos to help them understand what to keep in mind for the future.
- Reward Positive Behaviours: Praise those employees who correctly identify and report simulated phishing emails to reinforce proactive security habits across the organization. This can help keep everyone on the team alert.
How Often Should You Repeat A Phishing Simulation For Employees?
Phishing simulations should be an ongoing practice.
Running phishing simulations monthly or bi-monthly might be a good starting point. Continuous testing ensures that security stays top-of-mind.
Staggering send dates and times will help ensure that employees do not anticipate tests on a fixed schedule. Providing additional quarterly simulations for sensitive departments is also a good way of building out a more robust phishing simulation program.
FAQs
Q1. Should we notify employees before running our first phishing simulation test?
It is considered a good practice to inform employees in advance that phishing simulations will be starting as part of the organization’s security enhancement program, without revealing the exact launch date or type of test.
Q2. What happens if an employee enters real credentials on a simulated login page?
Reliable phishing simulation tools never store sensitive passwords. Instead, what they do is capture the action as a credential submission event to measure potential risk while keeping actual user data secure.
Q3. How do we handle employees who report the simulated phishing email?
Start with positive reinforcement, like an automated ‘Thank You’ or a badge in your security reporting tool to acknowledge them.
Q4. Should executive leadership be included in phishing simulations?
In today’s time, executives are frequently targeted in spear phishing and business email compromise (BEC) attacks thereby making their participation in phishing simulations critical to overall organizational security.